Skip to main content

Ed Maw, Cedric Knight, Karen Banks, Liz Probert and Mitra Ardron during the online interview.

Between 1982 and 1987, several independent, national, non-profit computer networks emerged as viable information and communication resources for activists and organisations – most founded by a small number of people devoting their personal equipment and free time to these endeavours. One of them was GreenNet, founded in December 1985 to provide professional computer capability to organisations working for a better world. Today, 40 years later, the internet has changed dramatically, and the ideal of openness and collaboration that characterised its early days is being increasingly challenged by a corporate model based on the concentration of power and a lack of transparency and accountability. But GreenNet is still here, providing internet services, web design and hosting to supporters of peace, the environment and human rights – better and more necessary than ever.

GreenNet was recently featured in The Guardian as a more ethical alternative to Big Tech, after having been named the top broadband and email provider in the UK. Along the way, they have achieved significant milestones – including the founding of APC itself in 1990 along with six other peers in the US (the Institute for Global Communications, then known as PeaceNet/EcoNet), Sweden (NordNet), Canada (The Web), Brazil (IBASE), Nicaragua (Nicarao) and Australia (Pegasus).

To celebrate 40 years of supporting environmental and social change, we talked to five people involved in different stages of GreenNet, from its creation to its present-day operations: Ed Maw, Cedric Knight, and Liz Probert, all current members of the team; Karen Banks, APC’s director of operations who helped build GreenNet in the 1990s; and its co-founder Mitra Ardron, who was there when they “put the first machine online, in my hallway at home.”

When reflecting on what has changed over these 40 years of digital communication, they emphasise that nurturing autonomy, self-hosted infrastructure, decentralised networks and small communities engaging with one another remains fundamental. Read on.

This interview has been edited for clarity and length.

GreenNet just completed 40 years operating. What was the inspiration, or the need, that brought people together to establish GreenNet in those early days? What were some of your founding principles?

Mitra: The inspiration for me was I'd been doing some volunteer work with various people around technology. I was familiar with email and most people weren't. And I took a fact-finding trip to the US, to California in '85. I met Mark Graham and they were just putting together PeaceNet, and I met the Econet people who were a completely separate organisation at the time, and came back to London inspired enough to put a server up; and that was the same as a bulletin board system, but it was there because we saw the need for NGOs to have the same kind of access to technology that the military and all the bad guys had.

PeaceNet were doing the same thing, so there was a lot of sharing of ideas right from the beginning, before either of us had servers online. That was how we ended up starting APC a few years later. In London we had a server that worked very well because people could dial in on a local call anywhere. And we had people in Europe trying to get to us, but they were paying international X.25 rates, which was stupidly expensive. People kept wanting to work with us and we were like, we don't have the capabilities to work in other countries; we needed to do something that's about creating capacity and creating other partners, not about people dialling in to us in London. That was the inspiration behind creating the APC.

From then we had to push quite hard for it because at the time, GreenNet and PeaceNet were both under-resourced... it was like, "Why are we focusing on all this international stuff?" Mark and I were like, "No, this is really important. It's not just about our countries, it's about everybody." We got a little bit of money, and I basically took a year unpaid with the first APC business card to get it off the ground in '89.

So what did using GreenNet as a service actually look like day to day in those early days?

Mitra: You'd dial into a local number, plug a phone line into your computer, use a program to dial into a service where you'd type "go GreenNet" or something, I forget what the exact command was. That would connect you to our service. It was all typed text on a screen, and you know, menus.

And it was mostly email. Email was the main thing. Then gradually, once we started using the software that PeaceNet had developed, then we had the forums, which became the main thing that GreenNet was really known for in those days. It was like you brought together all the people who were doing rainforests and you put them in one place. By bringing together all the people who were professionally doing something, we created value that just wasn't there before. A way for them to talk to each other, before they could make international phone calls, before there was any other online stuff at all.

Ed: We're still hosting and working with rainforest groups. On the founding principles, I'm wondering how much of that was driven by the NGOs that you were working with, and there’s this academic, Peter Willets, who was saying that APC was in a way a foundation of the internet, because it wasn't different bulletin boards competing with each other; there actually was an incentive to cooperate.

Mitra: APC was always, right from the beginning, it was designed as a network of peers.

Karen: We were very much North American, Western European-focused, even in the very early '90s. When I joined in 1990-1991, what was so inspirational was the idea that we could connect with NGOs, activists, women's rights groups in sub-Saharan Africa, in South Asia, where the cost of connecting internationally was completely prohibitive. You're talking about the days of information being shared by fax; a US dollar a page, which was the equivalent of a day's salary for many people. These kinds of economics.

So I think those bridges that were built using different technology... still dial-up, using very cost-effective compression technologies made it possible for us to start building networks and relationships with communities that expanded those to the world. Some of the first people who were using email and sharing information were facilitated by APC. That was pretty mind-blowing, really. And I don't know if you experienced this as well Mitra, but you know the kind of relationships we built with people through building that infrastructure, you know there were relationships for life. I may not have seen some of those people for 20-30 years, but it doesn't matter, because what we were doing was so pioneering. It was really, really special.

In terms of principles, it was very much about trying to balance everything... the content online, which was primarily from the West and North. Generating content from a Global South perspective. Providing opportunities for people to participate in processes. 

You know that whole period in the '90s, UN conferences, APC facilitated information exchange and participation in that was really critical. Whenever people ask about what was so special... I think that period of just building those relationships and networks certainly for me was really, really inspirational.

Mitra: Partly, most of those relationships were across countries, across politics, across quite a wide spectrum. And I think one of the principles, I don't know if it's ever been written down, but it was really key, and came out a lot in the APC meeting was, we were progressive, we weren't one faction of the progressive movement. 

There was a wide spectrum of opinion, and right from the beginning we were clear: we don't take sides within that. As long as you're basically progressive, you're welcome on this system. 

You're welcome to argue and debate with each other, but we as a network are not the network of just one bit of the movement, we're the network of everybody. I think that was quite important.

Back then, what did you imagine the internet would be like in 40 years?

Karen: I probably would have started using it a good few years after you, Mitra. It definitely was when I first encountered GreenNet, I guess we're talking 1990-sometime. How did I experience it then? Well, the thing is I had this experience, a kind of levelling experience with the people I was mainly working with. And it was very simple: we were just sharing, talking in words. There was no web, no Snapchat, no YouTube, none of that stuff. It was about building relationships, and shaping ideas, and sharing perspectives about all kinds of issues using words.

I have to be honest, as soon as the web came along, I thought, "Oh yeah, this is really going to change the way things develop," because you instantly garnered the interest of business and then governments. And of course, we know that things have changed phenomenally since then. So, how did I imagine it? I definitely didn't imagine this, what we have now. It's very hard to put yourself back there. I think what I imagined were not good things, sadly. The road APC took from the 2000s on was really about dealing with that very changed context, and we continue to do so, and I imagine GreenNet does as well.

I think GreenNet is a very interesting entity to look at, because you're still here 40 years on. If you ever needed something to convince you of how small is beautiful! I think I don't know of any other group of people that has continued, not only continued, and been through some very difficult times, I know very difficult times... and is now really solid and steadfastly there... I think doing even better. I think it's really worth reflecting on that, because I think that a lot of the kind of things we're talking about in terms of what does the future look like... I think we need to really reflect on some of the ways it has worked for us in the past: sovereign, self-hosted infrastructure, decentralised networks, small communities engaging with one another.

APC's network in 1994.

Cedric: I wanted to go back to what Karen was saying about the question you had about how the future seemed in the 90s. Yeah, it was quite exciting to be online in '93 and be able to get the APC newsgroups from Oaxaca or Nicaragua, or have these discussions about activists organising locally. Actually, it seemed like at that point we were going to have a global network of activists, and that was the way the whole internet was going, you would have much more citizen reportage. Of course, it didn't work like that because it became commercialised again. It's interesting to me the way that it's run now for profit, everything that we've lost… what was a kind of walled-garden aspect, in that it was all people with a general progressive attitude, whatever their individual ideologies were. There was a particular ethos there. That's sort of been washed out. So yes, "Small is beautiful."

I keep saying we're direct competitors to Google, and people say, well, "Google is bigger," and I say, "Yes, but only in terms of size." Everything other than size we're bigger. 

In terms of camaraderie and yes, all those kinds of things. I guess there's still some of that ethos. The way to keep that, and to keep particular groups talking to each other, they can do that through mailing lists. Mastodon is the thing we now sort of would like to promote, because you generally find politer people on it than on Twitter/X.

Mitra: There's a nice line from when we started, like the early days of the internet, we're talking '90s whatever, you'd meet people and they'd say, "Oh, I can't believe there was a time when you couldn't send email from one account to another unless you both had an account on the same system.” Now we're back at the point where it's like, with messages, we can't believe there was a time when you could send a message to everybody, no matter where you were. We've gone from balkanised email systems to everything talking to everything, back to balkanised again.

That was one of the big surprises to me on the internet. I thought we'd continue to be driven by standards, and there would continue to be the advantage for people to use the standard, rather than to build the walled gardens. When all the small organisations got together, we had more users than the walled gardens. And then that got flipped around at some point.

Cedric: A pleasant surprise was that we got a lot more open data in the 2000s. We got Wikipedia developed, which makes the internet go, I think. And things like OpenStreetMap, all those kinds of things that led to Web 2.

What makes you proud of the work that you are doing today?

Ed: We work with lovely people, and they're kind of small victories. But it's things like helping students in Gaza, three women students who one of our customers is in contact with in Gaza. Helping an organisation who are supporting migrants and refugees in the UK. 

Helping an activist on the union of a very high-profile media organisation... just helping them run their members list and do all this stuff online. None of this is really big, big deals, or stuff that we can shout about online very explicitly, because obviously our users' confidentiality is something critical to GreenNet. But those sorts of relationships, many of those relationships have got really, really long histories at GreenNet, based on the work that Karen and Mitra did.

Liz: I guess proud that we're still existing, because it's not always that easy with all the competition from big business these days.

To be able to still be helping small charities, activists with their email and with their mailing lists or whatever it is, tools that they're using for their activism. 

So I think, you know, surviving in recent years we've sort of taken on a load of customers from other co-ops that were trying to do similar things and had to give up, you know, and so we got new people through that, which is sad because those other things finished; but somehow we managed to survive and support those people. And we had a thank-you message from one of the new people just very recently. And that sort of thing is lovely. The messages you get from users, sometimes when they pay their bill, they send us a lovely card... it's just different to working anywhere else.

Mitra: GreenNet is still doing great work 40 years later... I would never have imagined that. I thought we were filling a niche of a problem that needed solving in 1985. The fact that it's still out there solving those problems in 2026 is just amazing to me.

Imagine the 50th anniversary of GreenNet: What do you think the internet will look like 10 years from now? Is there anything that worries you? Or a wish you could make?

Mitra: In the late '80s, the internet was doubling in size every six months. Anyone who was not on the internet had no idea, could not conceive of something that doubled every six months compound. And the change that wrought on the world was phenomenal. And we're seeing exactly the same thing happening with AI. It's doubling every six months. There's both positives and negatives coming out of it. But like it or loathe it, it's going to fundamentally change the world, and change the way we do technology. For good or bad, and I firmly believe that you engage with these things to make sure the outcome is good. I'm not saying it's good, I'm not saying it's bad. I'm saying it's going to make massive change, and we need to make sure that, just as we had to with the internet, we had to make sure or try and make it in both a less bad and a more good way.

Ed: At the same time, I do wonder if a lot of the people who are boosting AI at the moment are basing that model on the early internet model, and boosting it in very similar ways: "This is going to be a world-changing technology," because that's the model they have in their brains. But I hope, in 10 years, that the hype of AI will have cooled down a lot, and where it is useful, and the use cases will have established themselves in a much less hysterical way than what's going on at the moment.

Karen: Thinking back, I think what we've got to remember is that what we worked really hard to do was to make sure that everyone who was going to be impacted by the development of technology was involved in its evolution. And that's where APC’s Women's Rights Programme came from, that's where our current work with gender-diverse people, marginalised communities... And I think that's really our great challenge. 

We've got to keep people at the centre, and it has to be a very diverse, kind of plural approach, an inclusive approach. And that is just getting harder and harder and harder. 

I think we did some phenomenal work in the 2000s, trying to integrate gender and diversity into some norms and standards, but you know, it's a different world now. That is still what I think APC considers really critical, particularly when it comes to AI. But how we can influence the evolution of AI, I just really don't know how we can do that in a significant way, such that it reflects the plurality and diversity of peoples everywhere.